Deluge of Lawsuits by Angry Madoff Investors Expected
A little more than a week after authorities say the veteran money manager confessed to a $50 billion swindle, only a handful of lawsuits had been filed in U.S. courthouses by investors seeking to recoup losses.
Lawyers are working overtime, though, to investigate the case and say they are sure that the scandal will ultimately spur plenty of court action — perhaps for years to come. When the big cases are filed, they are likely to seek huge damages, and many of the lawsuits will likely be consolidated.
For now though, lawyers say many stunned Madoff clients are not yet mentally ready to explore court remedies as they grapple with the reality that their life savings may be gone.
“People all over the country are still in shock at hearing that their millions have evaporated,” said Jan Soifer, special counsel at law firm Baron & Budd PC.
Even while people are clamoring to sue, lawyers who specialize in investor claims say they are still sorting through the situation and formulating legal strategy. They say they only want to bring cases they think they can win.
“We’ve been conducting an investigation into what, if any, legal remedies are available to those who have been in effect robbed by Mr. Madoff,” said Robert Schachter of law firm Zwerling Schachter & Zwerling LLP.
“Our goal is to come up with something that we think will hold water in court,” he said.
While federal prosecutors, the FBI, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and others are examining Madoff’s business and looking for any potential investor recoveries, plaintiffs’ lawyers are launching their own probes. These law firms often have their own staffs of forensic accountants, fraud examiners and private investigators.
Should Madoff himself prove insolvent, as he has told federal investigators, that would mean aggrieved investors would have to explore cases against other defendants.
One group expected to face an onslaught of lawsuits is the hedge fund firms that handed over investor money to Madoff to manage, often without the clients’ knowledge, lawyers say.
A few court cases have already been filed. In one, asset manager Ascot Partners LP was sued by the New York Law School over the school’s investments in Madoff’s firm.
The lawsuit, filed on Tuesday in U.S. District Court in New York, contends that Ascot, as well as its general partner J. Ezra Merkin and auditor BDO Seidman LLP, were negligent by handing over “virtually the entire investment capital” of Ascot to Madoff to manage.
In past financial scandals, shareholders often have been quick to file legal action, in part because there were more readily identifiable defendants, legal experts say.
After the disclosure of a massive accounting fraud at WorldCom in June 2002, for instance, it took only days for plaintiffs to sue the telephone company, former executives and auditor Arthur Andersen LLP.
But here, legal experts say, it may not be as clear as to who could be sued given that investors got into Madoff’s fund in various ways — some had a personal relationship with the trader and invested directly, while others got in through asset managers who invested on their behalf.
Some investors, such as nonprofit groups like charities, could also be waiting to sue because they hope that state attorneys general or other authorities will ultimately bring cases on their behalf, Soifer said.
For now, investor lawyers say their probes are continuing — investigations that could take months rather than days.
“I will be looking for liability and collectibility,” said Scott Berman, a partner at Friedman Kaplan Seiler & Adelman LLP. He said his firm is considering suing anyone who can be found responsible for directing investors to Madoff and who has the money to pay damages.
(Reporting by Martha Graybow in New York and Svea Herbst-Bayliss in Boston)