With Rates on the Level, ‘Stable’ Personal Lines Move to Growth: AM Best
The regulatory environment for U.S. personal lines insurers is shifting from a focus on rate increases toward affordability, underwriting transparency, and oversight of artificial intelligence and predictive modeling, according to AM Best.
In its latest Market Segment Outlook, AM Best said much of the corrective pricing implemented in recent years is now in place, improving rate adequacy and stabilizing capacity. With fewer rate filings, regulators have more time to evaluate requests, contributing to faster approvals and allowing some carriers to ease restrictions or reenter previously constrained markets.
However, regulatory scrutiny is increasingly extending beyond the size of rate increases to how insurers develop rates and make underwriting decisions. New York’s AI guidance and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners’ AI Model Bulletin reflect growing concerns about the fair use of advanced analytics and preventing unintended discriminatory outcomes. More than 10 states have adopted the bulletin, while Colorado has implemented requirements for insurers to demonstrate that underwriting practices do not produce unfair results.
AM Best also pointed to affordability and availability challenges, particularly in catastrophe-exposed areas. Growth in homeowners residual markets has increased attention on the financial strength of participating carriers and potential assessments on the admitted market. In personal auto, continued premium increases could lead consumers to reduce coverage or drive uninsured.
AM Best said it maintains a “stable” outlook for U.S. personal lines, but competition for profitable growth could be challenging for some carriers now that a period with a focus on rate adequacy has eased.
“While the profitability in the personal lines segment has rebounded, a sense of heightened competition on pricing will test whether insurers can sustain those gains,” said Chris Draghi, director, AM Best.
Strategies for growth need to “protect the underwriting gains achieved through corrective action and avoid releasing margin too soon,” AM Best said in the report. “While results have improved, sustainability is key.”
Successful insurers will retain good risk without pricing it too low with discounts offered to attract the consumer – who may also be putting increased value on the manner in which carriers handle claims.