EU Moving Too Slowly to Tackle Health Risks From ‘Forever Chemicals,’ Auditors Say
The European Union is moving too slowly to protect people from the health risks posed by “forever chemicals,” with many substances still untested and unrestricted and legal limits for food and drinking water based on outdated science, the EU Court of Auditors (ECA) said on Wednesday.
PFAS break down very slowly in the environment and have been linked to higher risks of certain cancers, thyroid disorders, reproductive problems and weakened immune systems.
Read more: EU Plans Ban on ‘Forever Chemicals’ in Consumer Products
“We are in a race against time. Most PFAS are not registered under REACH, the EU’s system for regulating chemicals,” JoĆ«lle Elvinger, the ECA member responsible for the report, told reporters.
She said an EU restriction takes an average of 11 years to come into force, including six years for hazard assessment and five years for the restriction process itself.
“Moreover, once a PFAS is restricted, it often leads to a ‘regrettable substitution’. This means that a restricted PFAS is replaced by another PFAS that may pose similar risks.”
While the ECA cannot force policy changes, its reports often increase pressure on the European Commission and EU governments to act.
Most PFAS fall outside REACH because they do not meet its registration criteria or its minimum import threshold of 1 metric ton a year. Only substances imported in volumes above 1,000 tons a year require full toxicity testing data.
Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), one of the most widely used PFAS polymers and a key ingredient in non-stick cookware and waterproof textiles, does not have to be registered under REACH.
France and Denmark have introduced tighter restrictions rather than waiting for EU legislation. France’s ban on the import and sale of certain PFAS-containing products, including cosmetics, clothing and ski wax, took effect in January. However, more than a third of EU countries do not carry out checks to enforce existing rules.
Out-of-Date Limits
PFAS enter the human body mainly through food and drinking water contaminated by landfills, firefighting foam, industrial emissions, farming and wastewater.
Read more: EU Restricts Use of ‘Forever Chemicals’ in Firefighting Foams
While the ECA found that compliance with existing EU limits for PFAS in drinking water was generally high, and some countries have imposed stricter standards, those limits are based on science that is around a decade old.
For food, the report found compliance and testing across EU countries were “varies significantly.”
“If certain foods contained the maximum permitted PFAS level, a person could exceed their tolerable weekly intake after eating only around 7 grams of anchovies, 39 grams of wild salmon, 181 grams of eggs, or 237 grams of beef,” Elvinger said.
Trifluoroacetic acid (TFA), a breakdown product of industrial chemicals and pesticides, is among the substances that are not monitored despite being “the most abundant environmentally present PFAS,” the report said.
“The Commission is considering a ban on PFAS in consumer goods such as cosmetics, food contact materials and outdoor clothing, while allowing use in critical cases under strict conditions until alternatives are available,” a Commission spokesperson said in response to the report.
The European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) is expected to submit its final assessment of a potential PFAS ban next month. The Commission will use that assessment to develop its proposal.
(Reporting by Julia Payne. Editing by Mark Potter)