Ill. High Court Tosses Out Fraud Claim for Lack of Proximate Cause
The Illinois Supreme Court last week reversed an appellate court decision and reconfirmed that deceptive advertising cannot be the proximate cause of damages under the Illinois Consumer Fraud Act (ICFA) unless it actually deceives the plaintiff.
“The high court ruling reaffirms the original intent of the fraud law, which was not to provide an opening for meritless lawsuits asserting ICFA claims,” said Laura Kotelman, regional manager and senior counsel for the Property Casualty Insurers Association of America (PCI), which had filed an amicus brief in the case.
The judgment came in the class-action case of Shannon v. Boise Cascade, in which several homeowners claimed that Boise Cascade, a manufacturer of wood siding, had practiced consumer fraud and deceptive business practices in advertising that its product was of good quality although the plaintiffs experienced problems with the product. However, all plaintiffs reportedly admitted they had not received any representation from Boise Cascade and that in fact some of them had purchased homes with the siding already installed.
In its amicus brief, PCI maintained that the appellate court’s decision would not only create a windfall for people who were not misled or deceived in any way, but would eliminate sensible limits that courts and legislatures have placed on false advertising claims.
The Supreme Court reversed the appellate court decision, stating that there was no genuine issue of material fact that the plaintiffs were damaged because of Boise Cascade’s alleged deceptive advertising and reaffirmed the original court’s summary judgment for the defendant on the consumer fraud count.
- Hippo’s First Connect Partners With Root Insurance on Quote and Bind Process
- New York City’s Biggest Taxi Insurer Is Insolvent, Risking Transit Meltdown
- How One Florida Engineer Charged Others With Fraudulent Insurance Reports, Testimony
- Lyft is a Motor Carrier and State Farm Can Be Sued Directly, Georgia Court Says