Obtaining Optimal Catastrophe Coverage
The complexity of the cat insurance market can make it difficult to keep pace with the
coverage options.
The savvy wholesale
broker keeps tabs on which surplus lines insurers have the appropriate capacity for
In the midst of hurricane season, insurance agents and brokers are reminded of the need for forward-thinking solutions that will help them obtain the best-possible catastrophe coverage for their clients. Although the past two hurricane seasons were uneventful, commercial property owners and insurance markets are still highly exposed to catastrophe risk.
Following the 2005’s hurricane season with Wilma, Katrina and Rita, catastrophe risks were comprehensively re-evaluated and extensive structural changes made. Those changes continue to impact catastrophe capacity and pricing today.
Throughout 2006-2007, many commercial clients faced steep prices, restricted availability in terms of limits, higher deductibles and an overall shortage in the amount of cat coverage available to purchase. With the softening market, cat premiums have declined, and capacity has increased. Coverage has expanded, and terms and conditions have loosened.
However, the softening market must also be put into proper context. While cat risks may see double-digit decreases in premium, this is only after prior increases between 100 percent to 300 percent.
Due to those influences, agents and brokers must continue to develop plans to strategically market accounts and obtain competitive programs for their clients. The complexity of the cat insurance market and its various products can make it difficult to keep pace with the coverage options and to effectively evaluate the quality of insurance carriers. Thus, many agents and brokers are partnering with specialized wholesale brokerage firms, which have in-depth knowledge of the cat market and can provide the following seven benefits.
1. In-Depth Expertise
Property catastrophe insurance is a complex, multi-dimensional product that uses sophisticated language to define terms and conditions. A wholesaler with expertise in handling cat risk will understand the types of coverage. Wholesalers are also knowledgeable about program structure; primary and secondary structural risk characteristics; how cat risk models work; major catastrophe regions and zones; terms and conditions; enhancements; and program layering, as well as familiarity with surplus lines carriers.
In most cases, an agent or broker has some understanding of cat coverage but also represents the client’s complete insurance needs and offers various other services, including risk analysis, loss control and claims management. As a result, the independent agent’s proficiency is often across a broader area of insurance. Thus, many agents are complementing their knowledge of the cat market with the wholesaler’s experience.
“Catastrophe coverage represents a significant portion of our business,” said Dennis Kristan, senior vice president in the commercial division of The Rule Group, an independent, regional insurance brokerage firm. “We consider wholesale brokers who specialize in this niche to be crucial business partners, and we carefully evaluate and select the wholesalers we work with. … We rely on their expertise to suggest a placement approach and to help educate clients about catastrophe risk.”
2. Access to the E&S Market
Agents and brokers can obtain basic types of coverage for clients through the standard insurance market. For specialized or hard-to-place risks such as cat coverage, many agents rely on wholesale brokerage firms to access the excess and surplus lines market.
If an insured has a large portfolio of risks or property in cat-prone areas, the surplus lines industry may be the best, if not only, market to secure cost-effective coverage. The catastrophe-specialized wholesaler acts as the gatekeeper to that industry.
The admitted or standard markets are underwriting some cat risks. However, many standard insurers don’t have experience in this market. In fact, the standard market has had significant inconsistency in the availability of cat coverage and capacity. By contrast, surplus lines carriers often have steady, in-depth expertise, with specialized claims-handling services and a network of risk management professionals, consultants and attorneys that insureds can access.
As the authority on the nonadmitted market, wholesalers can help to identify and secure coverage from stable, long-term players. The financial strength of surplus lines carriers, with worldwide reinsurance programs behind them, has historically been very good, if not better, than the admitted market.
Most surplus lines insurers spread their cat risks over various lines and geographic regions to ensure they don’t have an “unacceptable” aggregation in one area. The savvy wholesaler keeps tabs on which surplus lines insurers have appropriate capacity for risk, as well as the skill, long-term experience and financial strength to underwrite a client’s cat risks.
3. Minimizing Client Exposure
“Even though the current insurance market has softened, the cost of catastrophe coverage continues to be a major concern for property owners,” said Michael Isaacs, senior vice president of the real estate practice of Sullivan Curtis Monroe Insurance, a privately held insurance brokerage firm. “Determining the appropriate limits of coverage is one the biggest challenges our clients face.”
Sullivan Curtis Monroe Insurance partners with several wholesalers for various lines of business because they have enabled the company to provide clients with a spectrum of products. All the wholesalers have one thing in common – a proven track record in their areas of specialty.
“For my real estate clients, our specialized wholesale broker provides valuable expertise in evaluating property risks, and we have a very collaborative process,” Isaacs said. “We discuss the client’s portfolio, the personality of the client and what they perceive as valuable in terms of coverage.
“What we’ve done especially on catastrophe business is to make the specialized wholesale broker a more integral part of our team and process,” he added. “Whether and when we bring them to a meeting with a client depends on the situation and the personality of the account.
“Sometimes, we’ll bring this specialist in at the onset of working with a new client. In these situations, they can better understand the client’s needs and there’s the additional advantage of having their expertise at the table,” he said. For instance, in California, the wholesaler can explain the nuances of earthquake coverage, how risk modeling works, earthquake zones and the philosophy of the surplus lines carriers. “They’re able to breakdown catastrophe coverage options and explain market conditions.”
4. Expertly Marketing Catastrophe Risks
“Our firm provides wholesalers with the information they need to represent clients’ risks to the marketplace,” Isaacs added. “The quality of the submission, how they handle the presentation of the submission to the underwriter and the depth of knowledge they offer are all part of what creates the ‘value added’ benefit of working with experienced wholesalers … In regard to placing coverage, the presentation of the account to the surplus lines market is crucial. Whether a wholesale broker gets the deal or not often depends on how well he or she presents and markets information.
“The wholesalers we work with are relationship-oriented,” Isaacs said. “They meet face-to-face with underwriters to tell the story of the insured. … They build a case of why an account should be priced at a certain level and handled in a certain way. Seasoned wholesalers present the insured in the best possible light to get the best results.”
5. Structuring Innovative Programs
When structuring programs, cat-specialized wholesalers may advise clients to place the account as one integrated blanket program, or to split the account and underwrite it by separate risk components. It all depends on the account and market conditions.
For large or complex risks, cat coverage may need to be spread out over several surplus lines insurers. In that type of deal, the wholesaler plays a “syndication” role, locating insurers willing to take on “layers” of the coverage.
Coordinating that type of program requires marketing and negotiation skills on the part of the wholesaler, who must be able to structure the program appropriately. In layering a program, the wholesaler maximizes the capacity any given insurer will offer with the broadest terms and conditions. That protects the insured from financial losses that may fall outside or exceed the contract terms.
Whereas in the past some large accounts may have required five to seven insurers to obtain the necessary limits, today the same limits can be obtained from fewer markets or even a single market. Yet, fewer carriers do not necessarily mean better coverage. A wholesaler can aid in determining the best solution.
6. Obtaining Best Results
In a close partnership, the agent and wholesaler will present the competing proposals to the client and will help select the package that best meets the insured’s needs. The selection and negotiation process must take a number of factors into account. Price is only one criteria. Breadth of coverage, risk management services, and an insurer’s financial rating and reputation for claims settlement also are important. Often, the account goes to the insurer with the right combination of price, terms and conditions, services, and reputation.
After the initial placement, the broker and wholesaler team may advise the client to periodically resubmit the risk to the market to determine whether better pricing, coverage or services can be obtained. In today’s soft market, a significant amount of resubmission and shopping occurs as clients test the waters.
7. Benefits From a Team Effort
Joint presentations and strong alliances position independent agents and brokers as insurance professionals capable of bringing a wealth of resources to the insured. Because cat coverage is complex, it benefits both the broker and insured to have a specialized wholesaler involved in packaging an account. Having the wholesaler at client meetings allows the agent and insured to delve into various program elements. The wholesaler may be able to provide the client with a better understanding of a certain cat market, such as earthquake, wind or flood.
In addition, meeting with the client allows the wholesaler be more closely in tune to strategic demands. Because the wholesaler knows how to structure programs, by being present to ask the right questions, the wholesaler may be able to offer or develop a creative solution, or obtain additional information to help market the account. Ultimately, the client benefits from the joint expertise, service and market alternatives provided through a strategic broker-wholesaler partnership.
- How One Florida Engineer Charged Others With Fraudulent Insurance Reports, Testimony
- New York City’s Biggest Taxi Insurer Is Insolvent, Risking Transit Meltdown
- Underwriters Wary of PFAS Amid ‘Superstorm’ of Litigation, Regulation
- Lyft is a Motor Carrier and State Farm Can Be Sued Directly, Georgia Court Says