Report: N.C. among states with worst traffic, S.C. among best roads

July 23, 2007

Nearly 52 percent of U.S. urban Interstates are now congested and traffic fatality rates rose slightly, but road surface conditions and bridge conditions improved, according to the Reason Foundation’s latest annual highway performance report.

“Gridlock isn’t going away,” said David T. Hartgen, Ph.D., the study’s lead author. “States are going to have to prioritize and direct their transportation money to projects specifically designed to reduce congestion if we are going to reverse this troubling trend.”

Drivers in California, Minnesota, New Jersey and North Carolina are stuck in the worst traffic, with over 70 percent of urban Interstates in those states qualifying as congested, the researchers say.

The study measures the performance of state-owned roads and highways from 1984 to 2005 in 12 different categories, including traffic fatalities, congestion, pavement condition, bridge condition, highway maintenance and administrative costs, to determine each state’s ranking and cost-effectiveness.

The report finds that fatality rates vary significantly from state to state. Massachusetts reported the lowest fatality rate – 0.79 deaths per 100 million vehicle miles traveled. Meanwhile, Montana’s roads were the deadliest, with 2.256 fatalities per 100 million vehicle miles. The national average was 1.453 fatalities.

The study does find some good news for drivers. The percentage of roads in “poor condition” fell sharply for both interstate highways and major rural roads. Since 1998, the percentage of poor urban interstate mileage has been reduced by 31 percent. The number of bridges deemed deficient, meaning they are eligible for federal repair dollars, also fell slightly in 2005.

In the overall rankings, North Dakota and South Carolina took the top spots for the second consecutive year. Meanwhile, New Jersey’s gridlocked highways, poor pavement conditions and high repair costs put the state last in overall cost-effectiveness for the eighth consecutive year.

Florida, California, Michigan and New York are among the states joining New Jersey in the bottom 10. When it comes to comparing the most populous states, Georgia (6th overall), Texas (15th) and Ohio (16th) are the top performing large states.

“The big states that score well have been able to achieve needed improvements and adequate maintenance at relatively low costs,” Hartgen explains.

The full report is available online at http://www.reason.org as is Reason’s 2006 study showing how congested each city in the country will be in 2030.

Ranking State Road Systems by Overall Performance

1. North Dakota

2. South Carolina

3. Kansas

4. New Mexico

5. Montana

6. Georgia

7. Wyoming

8. Oregon

9. Nevada

10. Idaho

11. South Dakota

12. Kentucky

13. Minnesota

14. Indiana

15. Texas

16. Ohio

17. Missouri

18. Virginia

19. Nebraska

20. Tennessee

21. Utah

22. Wisconsin

23. Maine

24. Oklahoma

25. Mississippi

26. West Virginia

27. Arizona

28. Arkansas

29. Colorado

30. Louisiana

31.North Carolina

32. Washington

33. Illinois

34. New Hampshire

35. Iowa

36. Pennsylvania

37. Vermont

38. Maryland

39. Connecticut

40. Delaware

41. Florida

42. Michigan

43. Alabama

44. California

45. Massachusetts

46. Hawaii

47. Rhode Island

48. New York

49. Alaska

50. New Jersey

Source: The Reason Foundation at www.reason.org.